
“Polyamorists love commitment so much, they commit to multiple people.”
I was recently asked an interesting question: What does commitment look like in polyamory?
In general, commitment can be summarized as ‘an agreement, promise, pledge, or decision to do something or to be a part of something’. Some commitments can restrict us from doing things, or limit our choices. Other commitments give us direction, stability, and the clarity we need to pursue a path or goal. In a relationship commitment means we have negotiated an agreement and are now dedicating ourselves to following it.
For the first 20 or so years of my dating life I was monogamous. I would meet someone, date for a bit, and then at some point we would have a conversation about ‘going steady’, or we would become ‘boyfriend/girlfriend’. At no point did we discuss exactly what this meant. My experience being raised in a monogamous home life and culture had taught me that commitment meant romantic and sexual exclusivity, prioritizing the relationship with my partner over my hobbies, career, and any other social relationships, and showing up for my partner in any way that they needed me to. So that’s what I did.
When I was practicing solo-polyamory I developed deep, long-term relationships that involved showing up for my partners and sharing my time and energy with them. Those relationships no longer involved exclusivity, or a blanket prioritization of the other person’s wants and needs over my own. Sharing myself with multiple partners at the same time taught me the value of understanding, expressing, and holding on to what I needed, and it taught me how to work with my partners to understand how that could fit with what they needed. It taught me how to negotiate.
I have a partner that I have lived with for the last 6 years. After a few months of being together we decided on a hierarchical relationship style where we were each other’s primary partner. There was no expectation of exclusivity, and the wants and needs of our other partners were important, but our relationship was the priority. Simple, right? Fast forward to a few years and a few new relationships later and it was a lot less simple. We had never really talked about what that relationship style meant in terms of our actual commitment to each other, or to the commitments we might make in our other relationships. We had not clarified where any priority applied, or where it didn’t, or how to go about making adjustments to our agreement as other relationships in our lives became more important. We hadn’t negotiated; we had assumed. And because of that we have now spent the last few years trying to negotiate how our commitment to each other actually applies to our day to day life.
To be clear, I do not think this is a bad thing. First, we had no real idea what we were committing to. We didn’t know what we didn’t know. Knowledge comes from experience, and neither of us had any personal experience with what commitment could look like in a partnered polyamorous relationship. We had read the books and learned the words and listened to the conversations, but we hadn’t learned how to apply that information and align it to our wants and needs. Second, we couldn’t predict the future. We had no way of knowing who would come into our lives, and how that could change what we wanted for ourselves, for each other, or for our other partners. And third, even without the influence of other partners, we were going to change over time, both as individuals and in our relationship, and we hadn’t considered what that might look like. In most cases agreements need to be reviewed and adjusted regularly, to ensure that they are meeting the changing and growing needs of all parties involved. We needed to learn how to do that.
So what does commitment look like to me now, in my polyamorous life? It means actively and intentionally negotiating commitment as an agreement that considers the wants and needs of both parties. It means allowing space within those agreements for growth and change. And it means a regular review of those agreements to ensure they are still working, and having the ability to adjust them if a change is needed.








